Season 51, Episode 8: Double, double toil and trouble

Season 51, Episode 8: Double, double toil and trouble
Photo by James Lee from Pexels

Shoot. Kristin. Kilby. My heart. What have you done, Jeff Probst? It just feels SO UNFAIR.

Well, chums, I guess that's just how it goes on Survivor. Don't get too attached. There's going to be loss, there's going to be heartbreak, but at least there's going to a really fun time at Ponderosa. Who wouldn't want to yuk it up with Kristin and Kilby and a couple margaritas? Do you think they have boardgames there? Cards, at least, right?

We fans get to experience a whole lot of delightful moments this episode. From Eric getting absolutely no response to his questioning about who voted for him to Maggie aggressively counseling Mike on his game play to a lovely and meaningful interaction between Lewis and Sharonda after their hard fought immunity win.

Preparing for Battle

First, a tribe name! Coming back from the last tribal, we learn--via a shot of the sign--that Tovuto is the name of the merged tribe. I guess that's the Fijian word for whale. I'm good with it. It's sweet. We love whales! If you don't love whales, I don't want to know you.

Mike is still the Toby of the tribe, it seems. He tries to do a "professional and mature sounding" speech but it doesn't even get to land because the Michael Scott of the tribe, Eric, takes over. Eric wants to know who voted for him but no one says anything. He's met with complete silence.

"I'm sure you have your reasons," he says, finally, after receiving nothing but blank faces. One has to wonder if they just don't feel the need to placate him.

Interestingly, Kilby later approaches Eric (whom he wanted off, but didn't ultimately vote for) with complaints about Mike. They call him a robot and then do impressions of him answering questions in a robot voice. Then Thien An and Devin also complain about Mike. Thien An is "fed up" with him "running around, causing paranoia." Poor Mike. We know he warned Kristin about her name being the vote last week, but are there other instances of him blowing up people's plan and leaking info? And then Maggie tries to coach/lecture him on his game play and how no one trusts him. She tells him he was the last to know about the Brady plan, but Mike was a driver of the Brady plan. He tries to get some understanding from her, but she's not having it. He calls her "Mags" which I find endearing, honestly. I think I need Mike's Survior memoir. The story of Mike from his own perspective. Because I think it's like a case of every move he makes being misunderstood. Is Mike the scapegoat or is he accurately seen as untrustworthy/bottom feeder/whatever?

But if any of these scenes give the viewer any impression that Mike might be in danger later, viewers would be wrong! It's all a red herring.

After everyone eats Devin's nicely plated tray of leaves and mystery nuts, Carter gets busy locking down a group of people who aren't "wishy washy."

It's amusing how frustrated everyone is with chaos. They all want control and certainty because of course they do. Uncertainty leads to anxiety and no one wants to feel that, especially when all day every day they are probably feeling it anyway. You can never truly feel safe out there. But this is the game. Everyone has their own agenda and it may or may not sometimes overlap with someone else's. They aren't an army with general making all the battle plans and then carrying them out. They are an island of multiple wannabe generals each trying to fight their own specific battle.

Nevertheless, Carter gives it a good try. He pitches a new--official--alliance to Lewis. A super alliance called Salt of the Earth which will consist of Maggie, Lewis, Carter, Thien An, Cristian, and Kilby. To solidify trust and safety, Carter shows Cristian his idol and tells him he's the only who he's showing it to, which I find interesting. Why Cristian? Was there more Carter and Cristian bonding that we missed seeing? Because last we heard, he was telling Thien An she was pretty much his ride or die. And before that he seemed mighty tight with Lewis, at least during the Patt vote off. Later, when it comes to players deciding what pair to go after, they are brought up as a threatening duo, so I'm guessing they come across as tighter and more dangerous than we know.

Everyone in the Salt alliance appears to be thrilled at the idea. But at what point do they find Carter too threatening because he's positioning himself as the leader? Carter doesn't seem to come off as too controlling, mostly just excited and eager. He sells his idea as one of reason: let's stick together to get farther. So for now, I assume people in the group will find comfort in that, but there's a lot of people in this group, so who knows at what point people get itchy. Also, tellingly, Eric is not part of this alliance. I don't know who Eric believes himself to be connected with, but we do know that Cristian has worked to keep him safe, so there was still some amount of Savu loyalty happening up to this point. If Eric finds himself on the outside, what might he do?

The Great Pair Off

Tree mail arrives with a directive: pair yourselves off. Evidently, this group had seen enough of Season 50 to know what this might mean, but based on the tree mail message, they figure it could also be a face-off. It's probably smarter on their part to assume the worst: a pair will be voted off together. There's still a big number of them and Survivor isn't known to do face-off challenges. Not one against one. Not that I can recall, anyway. Correct me if I've forgotten any. So everyone needs to figure out who they will pair with.

I wish this could have been drawn out for the viewers because I'm extremely curious as to what we didn't see. It appears to all come together pretty quickly, but given what they know about how much might be at stake, there had to have been more debate. Carter's plan is to pair with someone good at puzzles. Solid plan. That is what I'd do. But Cristian is also in his alliance and perhaps that is known so it is a little dangerous to make your pairing a two for one deal. Still, Cristian knows about Carter's idol, so he can help determine if it needs to be played to save them. Mike's idea is to pair up with someone who "doesn't share mutual enemies." Also a good plan. He asks Maggie to pair with him. She doesn't seem thrilled, but she agrees. I wish we could know if she was terrified or if she figured she was likely safe enough on her own that no one would go after them. Devin and Jelly– the most obvious of duos--pair up. Jelly tries to downplay their threat level, questioning why people see them as dangerous as they are just a pair of "friends" but no one can ignore the evidence of their survival through three three vote-offs (Jenna, Alexis, and Ori). It's evident they are not only tight, but powerful. I really don't know what they are thinking. It's so risky! Especially since neither of them are good at puzzles. But perhaps they see themselves as working well together and they know that Jelly's idol protects them both if it comes down to it. Although the way it's edited, we assume that they are a pair because they are who is leftover after everyone else, but can that be true? I want to see all the negotiations. I hope we at least hear more in exit interviews. How did Kristin and Kilby decide to work together? Thien An and Eric? Sharonda and Lewis?

At the challenge, we are shocked to learn that Brady asked to go home "almost immediately" after being vote off "to tend to his injured thumb" and I'm honestly baffled because the man stayed on to play after chopping off a chunk and while he's now not going to win, obviously, it's surprising that he wouldn't want to be on the jury and stay on screen longer. Plus, what kind of care is he going to get at home that he can't potentially get on Fiji? So, yeah, I'm wondering if it's more of a wounded ego thing, but I'll try to give him the benefit of the doubt.

We are treated to another challenge with new elements. It's both a reward (spaghetti dinner) and immunity challenge and it happens in stages. The first stage is a ball and beam balancing one, with both players working together to keep the ball on a board.

Kristin and Kilby go out first. Then Maggie and Mike. Eric starts rambling about everything from Captain Morgan to The Sopranos to spaghetti to Gina. No one seems happy about it. The four groups to move on are Eric and Thien An, Devin and Jelly, Sharonda and Lewis, and Cristian and Carter, who lasted the longest and win an advantage for the next round.

The next phase is each pair carrying bags of blocks through a falling tube and then basically shuffling boarding the blocks. Eric and Thien An go out in tight race.

Final round requires carrying the blocks with a prong across a balance beam and then stacking them strategically on a wobbly surface.

Carter tells Cristian, "It's like a school project." They do an excellent job of building up their blocks quickly. Devin and Jelly struggle the whole way through, losing ground just as quickly as they gain it. Lewis and Sharonda take the slow and strategic route and end up winning after Carter and Cristian's almost completed mountain of blocks topples over.

Lewis to Sharonda: "I saw the fire in you in day one. and I knew when you dropped early yesterday that fire was gonna ignite you. We did it."

It's a lovely moment and cool to see them so genuinely thrilled.

Jeff tells Lewis and Sharonda that they need to pick one person to send on a journey. Lewis immediately lands on Cristian, telling Sharonda, "I think he'd pull through whatever he has to do." Sharonda looks hesitant. I mean, we have no idea where Cristian currently stands with Sharonda. They are both original Savu and were strongly aligned when it came to trying to keep Linnea over Lewis, but it's a new game now and Sharonda is more tied to her Helicopter alliance and, as far as we know, Kristin than "original Savu" but there might still be concern for Cristians's well being at this point, from a numbers perspective. We don't know if she sees the journey as more risk or reward and what she might want the outcome to be. But who has time to think about all that? The pressure is on to make the decision and so she defers. And if you're Lewis and you look at the group, Cristian is a good choice given his logic abilities. He's more likely to at least save himself, if not get an advantage that helps them.

Next, they get to take two people to share in the plate of spaghetti with them. They choose Kristin and Jelly. Now, the big question is, was Jelly also talking a lot about spaghetti, or was he teasing Eric? I don't think he'd be mean to Eric in this way, but it weird, right. I need to know. Eric looks absolutely gutted. Spaghetti gate!

While eating the spaghetti reward, Jelly suggests to the group that Cristian and Carter would be a good pair to go after. She reports not wanting to go after the Mike and Maggie duo because "Maggie is well connected." But we know that she probably wants to save Mike because he's a number for her. I'm curious about the "well connected" argument. Doesn't that make them more dangerous? They have a lot of allies, which means they are protected and can go farther. Or is the fear that taking someone out who has a lot of allies, makes you more of an enemy? People will seek their revenge? Which is something to consider, obviously. But when there's a pair, it's easier to make a case.

The spaghetti group all admit that Devin and Jelly are at risk. In his confessional, Lewis calls their paring "the stupidest move of the game." He apparently doesn't worry about them playing an idol or what havoc him stirring up fear might wreak when he tells Jelly that he wishes "they didn't pair together." He is, after all, totally safe this vote.

Cristian kills during his journey challenge. It looks exhausting to go after all those buoys, but he's able to figure out the clue without any obvious danger to running out of time. During his journey, we learn that that he went to college at 15. He tells us he has a killer instinct when it comes to "strategic and ethical thinking." And I'm not sure what that means. I get it for strategic thinking, but what does it mean to have a killer instinct for ethical thinking? Me too?

Back at the camp, Kristin does her best to get in good with Maggie and lower her threat level. Maggie's not buying it. Once everyone has returned, the scrambling really starts and Lewis tells Carter and Cristian that Jelly is pushing them as the pair to vote.

Carter goes on the offense with Devin and Jelly and basically says, why are we aiming at each other when the easier and smartest shot is Kristin? He's not telling the truth, we know, because Kilby is in his alliance and because we know he thinks Devin and Jelly are the right vote. It's a good attempt, though and they appear to be swayed at the moment. They certainly carry on talking with each other like they are. They don't want to play their idol and their extra vote. And they see both Kristin and Kilby as threats.

If I were in Devin and Jelly's position there would be absolutely no way I wouldn't play the idol. I wouldn't risk it. It's the right time to play it if there's any chance you might go home. They know enough people have thrown their names out. They also know everyone else is going to feel more pressured to play whatever advantages they have. And it's a two for one save! Plus if you know most everyone else's vote might be on you, this gives you the power to really take out whoever you want.

Seems like pretty much the whole of Tovuto --with the exception of Sharonda--wants to vote off Devin and Jelly. And they are right. It's the smart move if they can do it. But no one seems to be (that we can see) making any plans for Devin and Jelly potentially saving themselves. The Salt Alliance does not think that Devin and Jelly have an idol to play.

And it might have worked, but for Thien An, who does what she's been angry with Mike for doing, and gives up the game. Sharonda outright asks Thien An what her plan is and she admits she's voting Devin and Jelly. Which tells Sharonda that others are voting Devin and Jelly (probably who she's connected with--at least who Sharonda believes she's connected with). Sharonda then warns Devin: "I think that you don't have the actual moves that you think you do."

Who does everyone think Sharonda is tight with? Original Savu? Thien An doesn't seem to consider that Sharonda might tell Devin and Jelly about the vote on them. And when Thien An asks Sharonda who she's voting for, Sharonda says, "I'm not voting Dev and Jelly and if it leaves here then I know it's you. No offense." As far as we can tell, she does not tell Thien A who she is voting for. And Thien An assures her that she won't tell anyone. Maggie is there right beside the both of them. Where is Maggie in this? What does Sharonda think about Maggie's allegiances? I wish we knew.

So, if Thien An hadn't given up to Sharonda that her vote was on Devin and Jelly, would those two feel safe enough not to play their idol? I wonder. Did Thien An's admission ultimately lead to Kilby's death in the game?

HOLY COW THIS TRIBAL COUNCIL, AMIRITE?

Jeff asks his usual questions about trust and certainty and chaos vs. calm. I'm not sure anyone is saying anything new. "You gotta just decide to trust." "It's hard to know." "I heard my name." "I don't know what is going on." Etc. People look nervous, especially Kilby. And whispering starts pretty quickly.

Jeff says to Maggie, "What I'm amazed at is most of you are absolutely nonplussed by the side conversations. It's like you don't even hear whispers. They're just all the time, so whatever." And Maggie hilariously responds with, "What did you say to me? What did he say to me? I'm trying to listen, Jeff!"

Jeff smiles. I think he used nonplussed incorrectly, by the way. Nonplussed actually means bewildered or baffled, not non-caring or not bothered or worried. Not chill. Maggie is indeed not chill. Maggie is trying to focus so she can know what's going on. Stop distracting her, Jeff!

Maybe there's just too many people with too much going on, but the Jeff questions seem less pointed so far this season after the merge. Last tribal was chaotic and this tribal is chaotic, so maybe Jeff has given up on leading anyone anywhere. Maybe the producers don't even know what's going down so they can't even prepare him. Doesn't it feel that usually Jeff gives little hints and clues about what's happening when he asks questions or brings up topics? When players tell us that "if they feel they are in trouble" at tribal they'll do whatever because Jeff is so good at teasing out what might not be known to everyone. "Ozzy, are you feeling in danger tonight?"

It's fun but it's not fun, you know what I mean? We don't know most of what's happening--what people are whispering to each other. We don't know if plans are changing or people are trying to solidify something. We see Cristian walk over to Eric and give him his extra vote to play because he's deciding he needs to play his shot in the dark for him and Carter, but what makes him decide this now? And why Eric?

And speaking of that, Eric asks what he wants him to do and Cristian tells him to play it on Devin and Jelly. He tells Eric that he wants this to solidify trust with him. And what does Eric do? He does not use it! Why? He says because he doesn't think it's needed. But it can only be used at tonights tribal council and there's absolutely NO REASON ON EARTH not to play it. Not unless he wants Cristian to be in danger. Probably Cristian should have told him to play it on another duo, just in case, because why not stack the odds, but I guess he had alliance members in all the other pairs, so maybe he didn't want to cause trouble, but still, that's the smarter move in my option. But I guess it wouldn't have mattered, but Eric made the decision not to play it. I sure hope we see Cristian react to this. It doesn't end up mattering, but it might have! And, again, there was absolutely no reason for Eric not to play it. Eric, my guy, what are you doing? Whyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy? If I'm Cristian, I'm sure as hell going to be pissed at Eric, especially after I've worked so hard to keep him safe in the past. Eric, there will be no more trust from Cristian!

My only theory is that Eric is doing this for attention. He knows this will get talked about. Or lack of food has made him lose all reason.

True to what we expect, everyone but Sharonda votes for Devin and Jelly. But thanks to Sharonda by way of Thien An, Jelly plays her idol for her and Devin. Kristin attempts safety for her and Kilby via her Shot in the Dark but they are Not Safe. Poor Kilby looks nervous as hell. Cristian follows with playing his Shot in the Dark and it is Safe. Kristin and Kilby appear devastated. Kristin goes first. Why? I don't know. Then Kilby. Poor Kilby. I know everyone wants this, but he played so hard. He gave it his all. Kristin too. Thien An's tears are all our tears.

There is too much math and logic for me to even consider all the different possible outcomes here. All the pairs, all the potential moves and advantages. Let's just say, it's wild. I wish I could tell you what anyone could have done differently other than maybe not put all the votes on Devin and Jelly. And I'm still not sure why Maggie is so safe and insulated. I do love this twist, as hard as it is to lose two people, it sure does make things more fun.

But, yes, this episode was brutal, because we lost two of our faves. I'm assuming they are also your favorites. Kristin and Kilby. Kristin for her cool factor. Kilby for his fun factor. I'm so sad that we don't get to see Kristin and Sharonda become a super strategizing duo or Lewis and Kilby engage in more highly entertaining plans for disruption. I wanted goofy alliance names and complicated game plans with cool sounded titles (Project Canada?). I don't think we are going to get these kinds of shenanigans from Eric or Mike. But at least we still have Maggie and Lewis to bring the chaos. And we have Sharonda to bring the cool. And we have Jelly and Devin as a dynamic duo. I won't be mad if Jelly wins. She's phenomenal.

METAPHOR WATCH:

We don't get much from tribal council this week so let's go back to earlier in the episode with Carter's farming metaphor after he tells us that he's frustrated with how everything is "haywire" and adds another insult to Mike's game ("leaking and BS").

Carter: I need to corral the troops. As a farmer, there's never a time that you just kick the cows out and hope they don't go to the neighbor's place or hope they don't get bred by that bull way over there. It's like, no, we've got a program (he makes a gesture with his hands indicating a square fence) and it's in this perimeter.

6 out of 10. I like a metaphor that relates to someone's personal life. Carter is a cattle farmer. And it's clear. He's gotta corral his cattle and keep them in the program.

Mike uses "pot calling the kettle black" to call out how others are doing what they have accused him of doing. And while it's a tired metaphor, it's exactly the right one to use, so I appreciate it. He's not trying to be fancy and flowery, he's using a metaphor we all know to give us the accurate picture of the situation. So, 8 out 10.

Kilby: Why be a chicken when you can be a peacock? Flaunt your stuff.

10 out of 10. It's simple and elegant and funny.

SIDE NOTES:

  1. I WILL NEVER GET OVER ERIC NOT PLAYING THAT EXTRA VOTE.
  2. Cristian does the beauty pageant queen wave when he returns from the boat and then giggles to himself. Adorable. He's quickly becoming a favorite of mine.
  3. My read on Jeff in his interaction with this group is that he finds them all annoying. Or at least a good lot of them. I think he's exhausted by them.