Season 51, Episode 7: Brody Down
Wha' Happened?
I gotta be honest here, I'm kind of feeling frazzled after this episode. The grubs were a lot, sure, but once everyone hits the beach together and conversations are afoot and names are dropping and miscommunication is happening and people are reconnecting and ass kissing and backpedaling and backstabbing and complaining and Brady and Eric are acting like bees on Adderall, well– deep breath--I feel like I just spun myself around a bunch of times and now have to walk across a balance beam carrying a tray of balls.
And that's before the wackadoo tribal council! All I know is Brady went home. I'm not really clear how that happened. I think it was Mike's doing? Or Devin and Jelly's? Or accidentally all of them?
In the beginning, we have Jelly and Devin fresh from another tribal council, having just having sent their beloved bud, Ori, off to Ponderosa, crushing his dreams of retiring his mother. They are tired of feeling the pain and heartbreak, tired of crying, and so they commit to playing the rest of the game with less heart. They don't say those words, but it's what they mean. They will do what they have to do to win. But when they walk in together to meet Jeff, they do look a little defeated. That is until the merge is announced and they rip off their pink buffs and throw them to the ground as if they were cursed objects. I guess they kind of were.
So now we are blue. I don't know if we have a new tribe name yet. I forgot to pay attention to that. Or it didn't happen. One of those two things. But they are blue! Which is fitting. And, yay!
Should they name their tribe Brody? Or maybe Brodies?
I Don't Want No Grubs
Probst does what he's been doing all season. He pretends there's good news and gets everyone excited about the good old fashioned merge feast before putting on the brakes. There's "a caveat."
"I love caveat!" says Brady, like it's a dish. And he does. He loves a caveat. Especially this one. Which is actually a dish. Kind of. If you count gross looking bugs as a dish.
In order to eat at the feast, they have to eat giant grubs. I don't know what the grubs will become, but if I had to guess they are future Mothmen.
Brady wants to eat a grub right now! And then Eric is begging Jeff to give him one too. He tries to turn into a sentimental moment. Almost crying as he's eating his grub. "You've just made a little boy's dream come true." On my couch at home, I'm not having it. There will be no sentimentality experienced by me when it comes to gross food on Survivor. No, sir. You can get emotional about finding an idol or winning an immunity challenge, but not about eating a grub. Stop it right now.
Players have to eat not just one grub but two very much alive and squirmy squishy crunchy grubs each and there are only 10 spots at the feast table. So they have to get them down faster. No puking allowed.
So mean.
Because I have an extremely sensitive constitution, I do not watch any of this. The sounds are enough. And it's a grub massacre.
Kristin is my hero for flinging hers into the bushes and telling them to be free. I feel like they should a least be already dead. Live giant grubs? I guess at least it's quick ending? But, gross. Gross gross gross. Brady, of course, is ready for more. I don't know what he's doing. He's about to eat a feast!
Jeff: What is so easy about this for you?
Brady: Jeff, I'm hungry.
Kristin and Cristian and Sharonda are the three that miss out on the merge feast. They use that time to come together, share info, and strategize. I don't mean to be too excited, but wouldn't it be amazing if these are the final three? I'm sure they would have all loved to eat some charcuterie, but this really is a special opportunity to lock down some plans. And they don't have to listen to Eric talk about Gina or his Halloween costumes. Nor deal with Brady being full Brady (or Brody or whatever), excitedly grabbing at food and stuffing his face with meat and cheese.
(Maggie looks like she's done with both Brady and Eric.)
Kristin takes the opportunity to share the note about the idol she got while on Exile. She wants to solidify Sharonda as a more tight ally. She has Sharonda keep the idol and be in charge of when it is played. I like this move. Sharonda can know that Kristin is for real locked in with her as an ally. It's good to have one person who has your back and you have theirs.
When everyone returns, we watch Mike make the rounds with folks, trying to sell his vote. He didn't feel safe with Toka, we know, but I'm not sure it looks good for him to be so obvious in his non allegiance, despite Eric feeling good about it. Does anyone have any space on their lifeboat? Anyone? I still like Mike. He's got a vibe I can dig. He's chill. I think that's actually what bothers a lot of people. He's too emotionless. People can't read him and he doesn't give up much about his game. But there must be more to it. Like, really, why all the Mike hate? Again, he's obviously frustrating people and being a little too obvious in his attempts to find safety and allies, but I'm not sure he deserves the resentment he inspires. Bottom feeder? Hopefully we get a bigger picture from future exit interviews. Mike, I like you, but apparently there's something really not clicking with your social game.
Kilby wants him gone because he can't get "a firm grasp on him." And that makes sense to me because it's easier to maneuver when you know who is with who. But if you can't get a handle on them, it's harder to do the math on votes. Luckily, Jelly sees something in him. Ultimately, though, it doesn't matter because he wins immunity and is saved by the necklace of giant teeth. Whale teeth?
When everyone returns from the immunity challenge, it seems Eric is the main name being floated. But Maggie does some whispering to Brady about Kristin and suddenly she's the one people want. At least the Toka folks.
Maggie calls her the "White Whale" and while I've never read Moby Dick, I know enough about the story to see this metaphor as not exactly accurate. But whatever. At least it is literary.
We know Maggie is threatened by her. She's too cool, that Kristin. Too smart. Too good at Survivor. Maggie, I'm loving how hard you are playing, but can you go after a dude already?
Maggie: Her personality is just wonderful. But I don't really want to play with her.
Mike wants to save Kristin and take out Brady. Jelly wants to take out Brady. Jelly brings it to Sharonda and Devin and they are on board. Sharonda tells Eric and Kristin that they want to flip it to Brady. I'm unclear as to what name Eric and Kristin thought it was. Because it doesn't seem like Eric is afraid for his life. We don't see Eric doing any fighting to stay. Maybe it didn't make the edit, but he doesn't seem worried.
Are we in a play?
It's hilarious that Kristin reads Mike's attempt to warn her as "bullying tactics." We know the history and background of his situation--we, the audience--know he wants to save her (and work with her)--but I still think if I didn't and I was standing there I wouldn't have read it the way she did. Mike a bully? Mike?
If she hadn't been so annoyed at Mike, would she have gone to Brady and confronted him? Because I'm having difficulty understanding her next move. For whatever reason, she tells Brady that Mike told her the vote was on her and that he told her Brady was voting her. Is she trying to get info or is she trying to burn Mike? It feels too messy and risky. But I guess she trusts Brady more than she trusts Mike, so she's doing her best to get a read on what's happening.
Brady: Why is he trying to turn us against each other?
Because, Brady, he wants to save Kristin and he wants you gone because you are too controlling!
It looks like Mike sees something going down between Kristin and Brady. He knows his cover is blown. (Can you imagine all the stomach flip flops that must have been happening out there?)
So Brady takes a seat next to Mike in/on the bamboo shelter. And this conversation, well, it's pure cinema. Or theater. One of those. Actually, theater feels more right. It's not about the visuals, it's about the words.
Mike: Dude (shakes his head). Talk to me.
Brady: No, Mike. You talk to me.
Mike: Talk to me! Talk to me.
Brady: I think you're frustrated right now, Mike.
Mike: About what?
Brady: About your plan not going according to--
Mike: What plan?
Brady: Flipping on all of us?
Mike: Dude. I'm not flipping on all of you.
Brady: You can't hide it anymore.
Mike: I'm not.
Brady: I wish I could believe you. I guess I can say it hurt my feelings. You know.
Mike: Dude, I'm not, I'm not against you. I'm not.
Brady. It's alright. It's alright, Mike. You know, the cards are on the table.
Mike: You don't want to listen to me. I don't know what else I can say.
Brady: Mike, I can't. I can't listen to you.
Mike: Dude.
Brady: You broke my heart like I was the girl at the prom, you know.
Mike. I'm not breaking your heart.
Brady: It's all right. What it came down to, I guess, was who Kristin was gonna trust. And you wanted her to trust you, and she didn't. She trusted me.
Mike: I don't know what to say.
First of all, this is like a scene from a mob movie or something, no? Like, chilling. A couple Brodies having a conversation, but it's ripe with tension. Confrontation. Betrayal. Denial. The stuff of true drama. An Arthur Miller play, if you will. Am I exaggerating? For sure. But, still. Thank you to the editors for giving us that moment. Mike against the wall doing his best to deny what had happened. And Brady pretending to be heartbroken (because I can't believe he really was) and doing his best to make a man uncomfortable.
Second of all, a girl at the prom? If she's at the prom that means she has a date to the prom and is probably happy to be there all dressed up and dancing with her friends. Unless she's Carrie? Then she might have reason to be heartbroken, you know, with the humiliation and pig blood. Or maybe the girl at the prom saw her date making out with another girl? What happens at this prom, Brady? I need to the whole tale of The Girl at the Prom. (Me? I didn't go to prom. Me? I was crying at home because no one invited me. So the better story is The Girl Who is Heartbroken and Crying at Home Because the Boy She Pines For Didn't Ask Her To Go). Let's fix your lines, Brady. You aren't heartbroken like the girl at the prom. You are heartbroken like the girl at home on prom night eating popcorn and watching the shitty VHS rental she got at Family Video. Or, to make it more modern, the girl stuck at home eating popcorn binging New Girl for the sixth time, wishing someone would kiss her like Nick Miller kisses Jess. Fuck prom!
Anyway.
I'm wondering about Brady's motivation in confronting Mike. It's not going to help his game to make to make Mike feel uncomfortable. If Brady were to survive, I know he'd go after Mike, but now Mike would know he was coming for him, which means he'd scramble harder to stay. I think Brady is genuinely annoyed and needs to have it out with him. Not heartbroken, but frustrated. And he wants to assert his dominance. It's funny to me, though, because Brady was already against Mike, already felt distrustful of him and wanting him gone. So Brady--in his heart--already betrayed Mike. Mike is trying to play his own game and he's right to go after Brady. Brady is an immunity threat and a social threat (sort of, in that he has allies) and if someone is trying to control you it's better to get out from under their thumb, lest you just help them win. But how dare Mike go after Brady?
Mike wants the vote on Brady and he's lucky that Jelly does too. "Something about going further in this game speaks me to me."--Jelly (right before we go to a shot of Brady pissing at camp). She's able to get Devin on board despite Devin once being buddy buddy with Brady. If Devin gives any pushback, we don't see it. So he either sees Brady as too much of a threat or he wants to give Jelly what she wants.
If only Kristin knew how much Mike saved her butt. It would have been her. Don't ask me what the numbers were, because I'm too confused too tell you, but this is my best guess as to how it was going to potentially go:
Brady, Maggie, Thien An, Lewis, Carter, Kilby (6) on Kristin
Eric, Sharonda, Mike, Devin, Jelly, Cristian (6) on Brady
Kristin on Eric?
But they wanted Kristin on Brady to make it go, obviously. I could be wrong, but this is the best I could figure.
But Kristin finding out her name is out there and then asking Brady about it makes it go back to Eric. But Mike and Jelly still want to go for Brady and Devin is able to get Maggie to see the Brady of it all. "He be blowing up all the plans!"
Thien An tells Mike that she doesn't want to vote against Brady so it looks like the numbers might still be tricky. We see them all march to tribal council and I'm not even sure they know what's happening.
Chaos
Jeff tries to get a sense of the day. It's funny, because Eric tells him that "everyone at home has the pieces" and "sees what's going on" but we don't, Eric. We don't! Because a live tribal is happening and I have no idea what is going down. I do know this: voting Eric over Brady seems silly. Eric doesn't really have any obvious sway with anyone. He doesn't seem to be a master strategist. He's not an obvious threat to win immunity challenges. And he hasn't shown himself to be sneaky. Brady wants him because he sees him being desperate but a desperate Eric doesn't seem that dangerous. Just busy.
At the live tribal Lewis whispers to Jelly, "I thought everyone was going Brady. I don'k know why everyone is talking so much."
Jelly: Because Kilby wants Eric.
Jelly: I'm going Brady.
Lewis: I'm so lost right now.
Us too, buddy.
Going into tribal it appears there were three factions: one wanting to vote Brady and the other wanting to vote Eric and then a small group of people who hadn't decided. It's hard to say who that small group was but perhaps Kilby, Kristin, Lewis, and Maggie. Actually, I really have no idea. All I know for sure is that Brady wanted to vote for Eric and Jelly, Mike, and Devin were voting Brady. Whose vote changed at tribal? I cannot say. Somehow Lewis ends up voting for Eric, though. And Brady looks absolutely baffled that he's the one going home. Maybe baffled is the wrong word. Stupefied? Not exactly shocked, but in definite disbelief. It doesn't feel like a blindside, but it's like he can't fathom that it actually happened.
Brady has no goodbyes for anyone. Hopefully he'll have a swell time as the mayor of Ponderosa.
Introducing a new thing I'm calling METAPHOR WATCH.
We will be talking about metaphors used in tribal council (and maybe other places if they stand out). You know how much I love a metaphor. And I think Jeff and the Survivor producers do, as well. But they aren't always good, are they? It is especially amusing when you know how hard the player tried to come up with a good one and it's obvious. Like, they've been planning this for years!
Of course we already talked about the girl at the prom.
Anyway, at this week's tribal council we get the following:
Carter: If I were a fly on the wall with a notepad today. I'd be on my 800th notepad.
On a scale of 1 -10 with 10 being the most excellent of metaphors, I give this a 5. It makes no sense. Flies don't take notes. But I like the absurdity of it. I like to think of a fly taking notes. A fly detective? A fly journalist? A fly working on his memoirs?
Kristin, in response to Jeff's question about the day being chaotic: Like a golfball in a tile bathroom.
4 out of 10. I mean, we get what she means, but golf balls don't really bounce. Right? I vote for ping pong balls instead. Or tennis balls. Bouncier!
Devin: We thought there were tribe lines and it's more like a web. And there's this web that's overlapping, overlapping between everybody. And no one can see through it.
7 out of 10. This is a good one. Especially because it responds to a common trope of "tribe lines" or "lines in the sand" that gets brought up a lot. It's a cooler, better way to describe what's happening. I like it. It feels organic and it accurately illustrates their tribe situation.
Kilby (on trying to lock down votes or figure out where the vote is going): It's like a wet noodle (as he holds out his hands pretending to hang on to a wet noodle).
8 out of 10. It's funny and it's true. And then Cristian gets to say he's "not trying to be noodle-y."
Eric: Every tribal is just one crazy party.
2 out of 10. It's true they are crazy, but I'm not sure about the party part. Parties are fun. At least they are supposed to be. It's kind of boring as metaphors go.
Side Notes:
- Honestly, what is Brady fueled by? There are no energy drinks on the island.
- Brady called out Maggie for having zero self-awareness, but Brady perhaps struggles with the same issue. Both are SO ANNOYED WITH EACH OTHER
- I will forever be haunted by those grub eating sounds. Not unlike the giant fish eye crunch we had to experience.
- Please don't do that to us again.
- Eric ate one and then learned he had to eat 2 more!
- Jeff asking us to apply holding that plate of grubs. I do not volunteer.
- "Bada-bing, Dudę!"
- I will miss Brady. But I didn't have to live with him. Maybe if I had...