Season 51, Episode 5: Standing on Business
What a show! And by show, I mean that tribal council, not the show of Survivor (but, yeah, also the show Survivor). Theater! Cinema! Good times! Thanks, Kilby and Lewis. And Maggie, too.
But first, poor Jenna. Not only was she voted out, but she had to watch the architect of her demise enthusiastically celebrate it. Fell to his knees and praised the heavens, he did. I guess we learned just how much her contribution to the Patt vote off last week angered Devin. Jelly, too. Jelly wanted justice for Patt. Yep, as suspected, Jenna never had a chance. The ole "swap screw" did her in.
I think I'm really starting to get why fans hate the three tribes situation. I resisted hating the concept because I do think there is some fun in it. More opportunity for chaos, perhaps. But it was nice to see everyone have more room to maneuver and strategize with the bigger numbers.
And now this time around Alexis doesn't stand a chance, despite her serious hustling to control the vote as well as her seeming lack of concern for her own butt. Alexis believes that Ori is 100 percent with her and will go to rocks against Jelly and Devin if there's a tie, which she predicts happening unless she can get Jelly to vote with them. She wants to get out Devin because she sees him as the biggest threat. She does her best to persuade Jelly to vote Devin, attempting to convince her that it's best for her game long term to lose him. Jelly does seem troubled by voting off another woman, but I think we all know that it's not likely she'll abandon the Helicopter alliance and her number one this early.
We don't see Jelly be irritated by Alexis's approach, but I can tell you that it would irk me if anyone tried to strong arm me that intensely. "You're crazy for continuing with him," she says, referencing Jelly's allegiance to Devin. It's aggressive and people get easily turned off by that. Don't tell me I'm crazy. It's condescending. Also, I'll do what I want! A better way would be to approach with thoughts and questions. "Devin is powerful and so charismatic. Is there worry that Devin might be too hard to get later?" Or something like that. I mean, Alexis did the same thing with Jenna and didn't win her over. Jelly doesn't seem to be bothered by it as far as we can tell, but we can't know just how much consideration she might be giving to siding with Alexis vs. trying her best to make her feel safe.
And then beyond telling Jelly she's crazy, she criticizes her game. "You've been mostly on the losing side." Alexis! Don't do that! That's no way to win hearts and minds during hungry and vulnerable times.
I like Alexis. And I'm amazed at her story ("running and gunning" on the streets, overcoming addiction, being a badass criminal defense attorney) and I LOVE that she fights for social justice. And I kinda hate that I'm attacking the aggressive play by a woman. But I don't think people like it from anyone, for the most part. And I still can't get over the demand for Jenna's shoes.
One thing the Shot in the Dark does is make people feel more inclined to lie so it doesn't get played. We see Devin do this with Alexis, who seems to buy into Devin's plan to vote for Ori. He doesn't say Ori's name--at least I didn't pick up that he did--but in a tribe of four people and knowing that Jelly is his number one, Alexis can assume that's who he means. Devin appears pained to lie to her, but apparently her playing her Shot in the Dark scares him enough to try to pretend he intends to keep her safe. So it seems Alexis really might believe she's safe here. She seems to believe that one of two scenarios is happening: Jelly and Devin are voting for Ori and she and Ori are voting for Devin. And then they will go to rocks. Or, that she, Ori, and Jelly are voting for Devin while Devin is, I guess, voting for Ori. Would there be any fear about going to rocks and having to draw with just one other person? That's how it would go, right? If they deadlock twice, then it's just Jelly and Alexis drawing rocks, while Ori and Jelly are safe? If she believes they are writing Ori's name down and not hers, then if they go to rocks she has a one in two chance of going home. Do I have that right? One would think she'd want to have her name be the one they are considering if she thinks they might go to rocks. Because then she's safe.
I've just extremely confused myself. I don't want to think about it anymore.
Kilby and Lewis are indeed worried about their butts. They are outnumbered on Dina and don't have the immunity after Mike killed it for Toka with his basketball skills. Lewis weakened his position when he was down for the count thanks to GI troubles. So the Savu folks feel closer to Kilby. Lewis knows he needs a miracle, but first he tries a Hail Mary in the form of a goofy piece of jewelry.
Yep, we need to talk about the "Blood Ring" or "Blood Idol" that Lewis tries to sell. Is it made with his wedding ring? He's wearing a ring when he tells us about it, but is that a different ring? When he hands it to Sharonda (and we don't really get a good look at it, unfortunately, nor do we see him make it so we don't know if it's something that was embellished or what, damnit), she looks dubious and says it "looks like something you were wearing." Sharonda practically rolls her eyes when he hands it to her. If I were Lewis, I'd be really struggling not to laugh at my goofy attempt. And then Cristian--who knows jewelry (what are the odds?), also implies it is made from the wedding ring that Lewis had apparently earlier described. Lewis, I like the idea, but maybe you should have come up with something different then what you had told everyone about. But desperate times call for desperate measures, I suppose, and maybe he didn't have a lot of time. I'm just hoping he didn't hand Sharonda is actual wedding ring to walk off with, but if he comes home with a million, I'm guessing his wife will forgive him.
So the Hail Mary probably didn't work, but the miracle arrives! Maggie! Sent from God? Maggie with two extra votes and a burning desire to see Linnea voted off.
We love to see how much fun she's having with her power. And during her visit, she is smart to pull the tribe members off one by one and get info on everyone's plan and allegiances. Overall, this is a cool move that will be great for her resume.
On the other hand, is Maggie smart to lay out her whole move to Toka when she returns? I know she has to tell them something, but when she gives up that she also gave them her own extra vote she's telegraphing that she has a big move under her belt and that she's willing to do big things. So now they are going to see her as a threat, if they don't already. With Brady finding her frustrating, too (earlier he expressed his frustration with her being too wishy washy) he could swing it against her should they go to tribal anytime soon. My guess is that Maggie could easily be in trouble.
The first tribal council of the evening goes as expected. Savu gets down to business and Alexis, somehow, is blindsided. She takes it well, though. All humor and grace. It appears to pain them all to send her home and one does truly get the sense that they all bonded and connected in meaningful ways.
"The more you get to know a person, the more you get attached their dream. You want to see them win."--Jelly.
But tribal council is all about crushing some dreams. Even when it's wild and dramatic, someone is going home and any fan knows just how much of a bummer that has to be.
Now we have Dina, our favorite checkout lady at Safeway.
Devens: I am the king of chaos
Kilby: Hold my beer
Dina arrives with four people probably thinking it will be an easy vote and two people probably nervous as hell. Probst calls it out quickly. "Two versus a four." he points out. And it would be simple ("Would that it were so simple."), if not for the Maggie of it all: two extra votes handed out to Kilby and Lewis and a clear directive to vote out Linnea.
Who wants to break down the Kilby situation? Everyone? OK.
So, Kilby's options were:
A. Do what he did. Use the extra vote. Force a tie. Force Linnea's (Lanaya, Laneigha, Lenaya, Lanayuh, Luneighah, Laneyah, and Lanayyaah's) exit.
B. Keep Maggie's Extra vote and stick with the rest of Savu and vote Lewis off.
For me, it came down Kilby's desire to pick the more exciting, and therefore, more entertaining choice. Does Kilby want a show? And does Kilby want to be the star of that show? Lucky for us, the answers are yes and yes.
The things that had to happen for Lewis to stay are amazing. I mean, we can go back to Carter getting picked for the potential mutiny trip to Toka then leaving his backpack behind to be rummaged through by Lewis and gang. Then Maggie getting the extra vote after Brady took over hacking the oar and finding it and being willing to give it to her. Then Maggie being picked to go on the journey, deciding to go to Dina tribe, and getting an extra extra vote to give away! If she had only one extra vote, it wouldn't have been enough to save them. So, luck is a lot of it, really. And then Maggie's gumption and her having it out for Linnea for whatever reason (she's clocked her as a threat). There's probably more variables we could dig up that needed to happen, but I don't have that kind of brain.
I'm wondering who Lewis and Kilby would have wanted to vote off if Maggie hadn't dictated. Sharonda? Surely not Cristian. I'm guessing they wouldn't have pegged him as a threat. And not Eric, because also not a threat and likely loyal to Kilby. Linnea and Sharonda are both smart, strategic women. But we don't know how Kilby and Lewis see them. Although it is telling that Lewis attempted to sell Sharonda on the Blood Ring advantage, which makes me think he sees her as the leader.
"This is going to be a hard decision."--Kilby
The funniest part of the Dina tribal to me is Kilby doing the show the whole way through--telling everyone about his extra vote but then "admitting" that it isn't useful to him at the moment. Pretending he's about to vote off Lewis. Does he do all this because he's worried if he doesn't play it up, things might change or is he just having a good time with it? Because would it change anything to not tell them about the vote and not pretend? Maybe it's just nerves. It's hard to say. But it's fun to watch it and not have any idea what is going to happen, because it definitely looks like Kilby might not save Lewis, until he does.
And he sticks with it, even though Eric, Sharonda, Cristian, and Linnea all try their hardest to get him to switch. When Kilby says it's too late for him to change, I agree. It's done. If he changes his vote to Lewis, he's going to have wasted all that effort for nothing. And now they'll see him as not trustworthy anyway.
Probst really gives Kilby and Lewis a gift here by first asking Kilby what he intends to do, letting him telegraph that he's not budging. Sure, he already announced he was deadlocked and had the Savu group come at him hard to try and save Linnea, but when Probst ask him his position, he made it pretty impossible for Linnea to fight back. They had to react to his position rather than have any kind of upper hand.
"Kilby, you are not sorry," says Linnea, when her fate is decided, but he does look actually sad whereas Eric looks like he's working hard to cry. I struggle with this one because I really was interested to see Linnea go far, but I also love watching Lewis in the game.
Did Kilby make the right move? He definitely made the more fun and exciting move. He makes Maggie happy and Lewis happy and if he makes it to the merge he probably has their loyalty. If he had stuck with Savu he would have shown them loyalty, but then he would be at the bottom of their group. If they were to lose again, he'd very likely be the next to go home. He and Lewis are still in the minority within that tribe, numbers-wise, but it isn't as dire and he could potentially bank on Eric saving him, since Eric likes him so much. Voting with Kilby doesn't really put him in a worse position. Lewis goes home and he's next. Or Lewis stays and they are still in trouble. Sure, they could go after him next out of anger, but he still might have Eric pulling for him. Of course, the bigger consideration is them coming for blood should they all make it to the merge. Do they zero in on him as a big enough threat to pull others together and vote him off? Or, if he's lucky enough to make it to final three or final two (whichever way it goes), does he lose them as potential votes? But maybe not if they see the move more than they feel the lingering burn.
But, to have an opportunity to do something big and bold for the game, but also, well, America, that's probably too hard to pass up. Winning the million is always going to be a long shot, but getting notoriety means more potential revenue on Cameo, more likelihood of being asked back on Survivor, and more chances of other reality shows wanting to cast you. It's probably no contest. You do the big move. Even if it involves going to rocks. I wonder if Kilby was prepared to go to rocks or if he knew--or at least strongly believed--that they wouldn't go to rocks.
We have now lost 6 cool, strategic players. All women.
Although one has to assume that if there are the three same tribes competing next week and Savu loses again, it's Ori's who is up. Jelly and Dev appear to be an extremely tight duo now. They each call each other their number one and Devin claims it was from day one, but I'm not sure that was clear to us. It is now. And if Dina has to go again to tribal, I'm not sure who is most in trouble between Lewis and Kilby. Hopefully more shake ups will happen. Permanent uncertainty, right? I'm game.
Side Notes:
- Lewis, you need to watch some Miyazaki films. But don't worry about catching up on any of that 90s music.
- Cristian knows jewelry and I love it. Cristian finally have a little moment to shine. And the bowtie!
- Love that Toka was practicing making hoops and then have a basketball thing on the challenge.
- Love to see another new challenge!
- Kilby flying over to vote again, lol.
- Maggie really.did.not.want. Kristin's coconut offerings.
- "There's macaroons in there, Brody!" yells Brady upon seeing the basket of pastries. So much joy for some macaroons. Actually, I believe he says macaroons but what I see in the basket are macarons and, well, I'm not gonna go into further details because it's not important.
- "Homeboy ain't Aquaman."--Kilby, volunteering to sit out the challenge.
- "Mike was insane on the balls."--Linnea
- Eric and his hand puppets.
- I swear that all the women are wearing mascara and how is that possible?